Sheetz Sandwich Menu: Sub Prices & Best Builds (2026)
A Sheetz sandwich is a Made-to-Order build: you spec it on the touchscreen kiosk or in the app, and the kitchen makes it while you wait. A standard 6-inch sub starts around $4.99, a 12-inch runs about $6.99, and named builds like the Meatball Marinara land at $6.49. Everything below is the full lineup, hot, cold, chicken and fish, with the prices this site has verified.
| Sandwich | Size | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| Made-to-Order Sub (build your own) | 6-inch | $4.99+ |
| Made-to-Order Sub (build your own) | 12-inch | ~$6.99 |
| Meatball Marinara Sub | 6-inch | $6.49 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub | 6-inch | $6.49 |
| Fish Sammie | Regular | ~$4.99 |
| Dockside Seadog | Regular | ~$3.99 |
Hot Subs
Hot subs are the core of the board. The meatballs, steak and chicken builds come off the grill line, and the two named subs below have carried the same $6.49 price across this site’s menu pages all year. A build-your-own hot sub starts lower, at $4.89+ for the base before extras.

Item: Meatball Marinara Sub
Calories: ~550

Item: Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Calories: ~600
Item: Protein Parm Sub (half, 6-inch)
Calories: 460
The Protein Parm is the quiet overachiever here: 460 calories and roughly 38 grams of protein in a half sub, the best protein-per-calorie ratio of any sub this site has figures for. The Chicken Tender Sub with Boom Boom sauce is the order regulars recommend most, and it is a build rather than a fixed menu item, so its price and calories move with what you add. Steak and cheese builds price like the other hot subs once you add extras; the kiosk shows the running total as you go.
Cold and Deli Subs and Hoagies
Cold subs are where the build-your-own system earns its keep. Turkey, ham, Italian-style deli meats, cheese, vegetables and sauces stack onto the same rolls as the hot line, and a 6-inch starts around $4.99 before premium extras. If you are in eastern Pennsylvania and you call it a hoagie, same counter, same board: Sheetz brands them Subz, and there is no separate hoagie menu hiding anywhere. It is one MTO list with a regional accent.

Item: Custom 6-Inch Sub
Calories: ~400-700 by build
Item: Custom 12-Inch Sub
Calories: varies by build
Item: Skinny Grilled Chicken (Eat Shmart)
Calories: ~420-460 (Eat Shmart range)
The Eat Shmart line is Sheetz’s lighter-build range, and most of its sandwiches sit between 420 and 460 calories, the Skinny Grilled Chicken and the Southwest Veggie Sub included. One quirk worth knowing before you order: the 12-inch costs only about $2.00 more than the 6-inch, so the footlong is the better value whenever you are feeding two people or one very committed person.
Chicken Sandwiches
Chicken comes three ways at the kiosk: crispy fillets, grilled chicken, and tenders folded into a sub. The spicy version is a real menu item, not a sauce trick — it shows on current delivery menus at a $5.29 delivery price, and in-store it prices with the other chicken builds. There is also a Big Mozz Chicken Sandwich on delivery menus, the chicken sibling of the Big Mozz burger.
Honest note on numbers: Sheetz does not publish a tidy in-store price list for each chicken build, and this site will not invent one. The chicken strips that anchor most of these builds are verified: 3 pieces at $6.59 (about 450 to 550 calories) and 5 pieces at $8.89 (549 calories). If you want the full burger-side story, the Big Mozz gets its own breakdown on our burgers page. For calories on any specific build, the Sheetz nutrition calculator prices out your exact spec better than any static table.
Fish Sandwiches
Ask for a Sheetz fish sandwich and you get a choice, not a single item. The chain’s current fish lineup, which this site’s homepage tracks, runs from a simple fried Fish Sammie to a full Fish N Chips Platter, and none of the top menu sites bother listing it properly. Prices below are the site’s published figures; calories for the fish line are not published anywhere reliable, so they are not printed here.
Item: Fish Sammie
Item: Fish Po’Boy
Item: Dockside Seadog
Item: Fish N Chips Platter
The Fish Sammie is the straight answer to the fish-sandwich search: a fried fillet on a toasted bun with American cheese and lettuce. The Po’Boy is the bigger, dressed-up build, and the Seadog is the budget pick of the group. Fish street tacos also appear on the board; they live with the rest of the Tex-Mex lineup on our MTO menu page. Allergen note: every fish item runs through a shared kitchen, so check the allergen guide before ordering for anyone with a fish or wheat allergy.
Grilled Cheese and Meltz
Yes, there is a grilled cheese. It sits in the vegetarian corner of the board alongside the veggie sub and veggie wrap, and it is exactly what the name promises: cheese melted on a toasted roll, built at the same kiosk. Sheetz does not publish its price or calories in the sources this site uses, so instead of a copied number from another menu site, the honest line is this: it prices at the low end of the sandwich board, and the kiosk shows your exact total before you pay. Breakfast has its own Breakfast Meltz line, covered on the breakfast menu page.
Build a Sub: What Your Choices Add
Most of the menu is a base price plus decisions. This table keeps only the impacts that can be verified, and says so where the kiosk keeps the number to itself.
| Bread | Protein | Typical price impact | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| White sub roll, 6-inch | Meatballs | Named build, $6.49 total | The classic first order |
| Pretzel roll (swap) | Meatballs | Swap; upcharge varies by store | The version a celebrity chef swears by |
| White sub roll, 12-inch | Deli turkey or ham | About +$2.00 over the 6-inch | Feeding two, or one big appetite |
| Flour wrap | Grilled chicken | Base price; tortilla alone is 300 cal | A lighter handheld build |
| Flatbread | Protein Parm build | Base price; flatbread base ~238 cal | Most protein per calorie |
| Salad greens (no bread) | Any protein | Base price | Skipping the roll entirely |
The costliest decisions are the protein ones: double meat and extra cheese are priced on the kiosk screen as you build, and Sheetz does not publish those upcharges in any source this site can use. Extra sauce dippers are the cheap thrill, about $0.50 each. Cheese choice matters more than it should: American, provolone, pepper jack, Swiss, a shredded blend and nacho are all on the board, and the verdict section below explains why sliced provolone beats the blend on a meatball sub.
Are Sheetz Subs Actually Good?
The most useful evidence is a ranked taste test. In April 2026, Chowhound ranked seven chains’ meatball subs worst to best and put Sheetz sixth of seven. That sounds rough until you read the split: the reviewer, a professional cheesemonger, praised the tender meatballs and the fluffy white sub roll, and aimed the criticism at the marinara, called thick, sweet and pasty. Her one build error was choosing the shredded cheese blend, which did not melt properly, over sliced provolone.
Then there is the other side. Food Network chef Duff Goldman has named the Sheetz meatball sub his favourite fast food, and he likes exactly what the ranking criticised: the way the sauce soaks into the bread. Both accounts are named here so you can weigh them yourself. Read together, they agree on the mechanics even where they disagree on taste: the meatballs and the roll are genuinely good, the sauce is sweet and divisive, and your cheese and bread choices move the result more than the chain does. Toasting and a pretzel-roll swap are the two upgrades regulars reach for.
Our verdict, for what it is worth: a Sheetz sub is a strong convenience-store sandwich and a middling deli sandwich, and it does not pretend to be the second one. Order the meatball with provolone, or the chicken tender build with Boom Boom sauce, and you are eating the best version of the board.
Orders Worth Repeating

Meatball Marinara, Pretzel Roll, Provolone
The Duff Goldman configuration, give or take a talk-show segment. Meatballs and marinara on a pretzel roll with sliced provolone that actually melts. Base sub is $6.49; the roll swap prices at the kiosk.
Chicken Tender Sub with Boom Boom Sauce
The order this site’s MTO guide calls the most-recommended on the board. Crispy tenders, Boom Boom sauce, your call on cheese and crunch. Priced by build at the kiosk.
Protein Parm, Half 6-Inch
The training-day sub: 460 calories, roughly 38 grams of protein, and it still eats like a proper sandwich. Best protein-per-calorie figure of any sub we have numbers for.
FAQs
Is the Sheetz meatball sub good?
It depends on the build. Chowhound’s April 2026 ranking of seven chains put it sixth, praising the tender meatballs and fluffy roll while criticising the sweet marinara. Chef Duff Goldman calls the same sub his favourite fast food. Order it with sliced provolone, not the shredded blend, and it lands at its best.
How much is a 6-inch Sheetz sub compared with a footlong?
A build-your-own 6-inch starts around $4.99 and the 12-inch runs about $6.99, so doubling the sandwich adds roughly $2.00. Named builds like the Meatball Marinara are priced as complete sandwiches at $6.49 in the 6-inch size. Prices are typical and vary by store.
Can you turn any Sheetz sub into a wrap or a salad?
Yes. The MTO bases include a flour wrap, a flatbread and salad greens alongside the rolls and buns, so almost any sub build can be re-based at the kiosk or in the app at no change to the base price structure. The wrap tortilla itself is 300 calories, and the flatbread base is lighter at about 238.
Is a hoagie the same thing as a Sheetz sub?
At Sheetz, yes. Hoagie is the eastern Pennsylvania word for the same sandwich, and the chain simply brands its version Subz on the MTO board. There is no separate hoagie menu, different roll or different price list. Order a sub anywhere in Sheetz country and you are ordering the hoagie.
Does Sheetz deliver subs?
Yes. You can order subs for delivery in the Sheetz app, where delivery is powered by DoorDash, and Sheetz also lists on DoorDash, Uber Eats and Grubhub in most areas. Delivery prices run higher than in-store prices, and availability follows your local store, so check your address in the app.