Sheetz Ice Cream Menu with Prices & Flavors (2026)
Yes, Sheetz sells ice cream, but the current ice cream selection is different from the scoop-and-soft-serve menus shown on many outdated menu websites.
The Sheetz ice cream menu currently centers on packaged Ben & Jerry’s pints and frozen treats, with Snickers Ice Cream also appearing at many locations. Recent Sheetz store menus consistently show most Ben & Jerry’s products at $7.99, while the 14 oz Snickers Ice Cream is $5.99.
Last checked: October 2026. Prices and stock can vary by Sheetz location.
Sheetz Ice Cream Menu & Prices
Here is the core ice cream lineup currently appearing across multiple Sheetz store menus:
| Ice Cream | Size | Typical Price |
|---|---|---|
| Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough | Pint | $7.99 |
| Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Fudge Brownie | Pint | $7.99 |
| Ben & Jerry’s Half Baked | Pint | $7.99 |
| Ben & Jerry’s Strawberry Cheesecake | Pint | $7.99 |
| Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Chunks | 8 oz | $7.99 |
| Snickers Ice Cream | 14 oz | $5.99 |
Some stores carry additional Ben & Jerry’s varieties. Sundae Cookie Vermont-ster, for example, has appeared at $7.99 on recent Sheetz menu data, but it is not as consistently listed as the core products above.
That distinction matters. Sheetz does not appear to maintain one identical nationwide freezer selection, so a flavor available at one store may be missing at another.
What Ice Cream Flavors Does Sheetz Have?
The most consistently listed Ben & Jerry’s flavors are:
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Vanilla ice cream packed with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough. This is one of the most consistently available Sheetz pint options.
Size: Pint
Typical price: $7.99
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Chocolate ice cream with pieces of fudge brownie throughout.
Size: Pint
Typical price: $7.99
Half Baked
A mix of chocolate and vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip cookie dough and fudge brownies. It combines two of Ben & Jerry’s best-known mix-ins in one pint.
Size: Pint
Typical price: $7.99
Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry cheesecake ice cream with strawberries and a cookie swirl.
Size: Pint
Typical price: $7.99
Snickers Ice Cream
Sheetz also carries Snickers Ice Cream in a 14 oz container at many locations. It is separate from the Ben & Jerry’s lineup and is usually cheaper.
Size: 14 oz
Typical price: $5.99
Does Sheetz Sell Ice Cream Pints?
Yes. Ben & Jerry’s pints are the main ice cream format currently found at Sheetz.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Half Baked, and Strawberry Cheesecake have all appeared repeatedly on recent Sheetz location menus.
You may also find Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Chunks in an 8 oz bag. Despite appearing in the Ice Cream category on some store menus, these are frozen cookie-dough pieces rather than a pint of ice cream.
Does Sheetz Still Have Soft Serve Ice Cream?
Do not assume that every Sheetz still has a soft-serve machine.
Sheetz previously had self-serve ice cream machines and toppings stations at some stores. That older setup is why searches for Sheetz soft serve, Sheetz ice cream cones, and Sheetz ice cream machines still appear frequently.
However, customer and employee reports over the past several years indicate that those machines were removed or phased out at many locations. There does not appear to be a current chain-wide soft-serve menu comparable to the packaged ice cream selection.
So if you specifically want soft serve rather than a pint, check your individual store before making the trip. Packaged ice cream is much easier to find consistently.
Does Sheetz Have Ice Cream Cones?
A cone is not part of the consistent current ice cream lineup shown across the recent store menus checked for this guide.
That makes sense because the current selection is primarily packaged ice cream rather than scooped ice cream. An individual location with remaining soft-serve equipment may be different, but cones should not be treated as a standard Sheetz-wide menu item.
Where Is the Ice Cream at Sheetz?
Packaged ice cream is normally sold from the store’s refrigerated or freezer section rather than ordered as a standard Made-to-Order food item.
Availability is particularly store-dependent. One location may carry all four common Ben & Jerry’s pints while another has only one or two.
If you want a prepared frozen dessert instead, that is a separate category. Sheetz makes blended shakes to order; the current flavors, sizes, and costs are covered in the Sheetz milkshake menu.
Why Sheetz Ice Cream Prices Can Differ
The prices above are useful current reference prices, not a guarantee for every store.
Sheetz operates a large regional store network, and menu pricing can change by location. Inventory can change even faster: packaged ice cream depends on what a particular store currently has in stock.
For that reason, $7.99 for the listed Ben & Jerry’s products and $5.99 for Snickers Ice Cream should be treated as commonly observed 2026 prices rather than permanent nationwide prices.
For the most accurate local answer, select your store in the Sheetz app or online ordering system before you leave.
Is Sheetz Ice Cream Dairy-Free?
The core ice cream products listed above are not a reliable dairy-free lineup. Ben & Jerry’s makes non-dairy products as a brand, but that does not mean every Sheetz carries them.
Do not assume a flavor is suitable for an allergy or dietary restriction based only on its name. Ingredients differ by product and formulations can change.
For food sensitivities, check the package itself and use the dedicated Sheetz allergen guide for how Sheetz handles allergen information.
Sheetz Ice Cream Calories
Calories vary significantly by flavor and serving amount, so a pint price should not be confused with a single-serving nutrition figure. A full Ben & Jerry’s pint contains multiple labeled servings.
The most dependable number is the nutrition label on the exact package you are buying. For broader Sheetz calorie and macro information, see the Sheetz nutrition menu.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Sheetz have ice cream?
Yes. Current Sheetz store menus show packaged ice cream, led by Ben & Jerry’s pints and Snickers Ice Cream. Exact flavors and stock vary by store.
How much is ice cream at Sheetz?
The commonly listed 2026 price is $7.99 for Ben & Jerry’s pints and selected frozen products, while Snickers Ice Cream 14 oz is typically $5.99. Local prices can differ.
What Ben & Jerry’s flavors does Sheetz sell?
The most consistently found flavors are Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Half Baked, and Strawberry Cheesecake. Other varieties can appear at individual stores.
Does Sheetz have soft serve?
Sheetz historically offered self-serve ice cream at some locations, but machines have reportedly been removed or phased out at many stores. Soft serve should not be assumed to be available chain-wide.
Does Sheetz sell ice cream cones?
Cones do not appear as a consistent item on the current Sheetz ice cream menus checked. Stores with remaining soft-serve equipment may differ.
Can you order Sheetz ice cream online?
Availability depends on the selected store. Check your location in the Sheetz app or online ordering system to see what frozen products are currently offered.