Sheetz Fall Menu 2026: Pumpkin Shakes, Coffee & Halloween
Sheetz’s fall 2026 menu launched on September 2 at all locations. The lineup includes:
- Three seasonal milkshakes: Pumpkin Pie, Pumpkin Cheezecake and Cereal Chiller.
- Three pumpkin coffee items: a new Pumpkin Chai, Pumpkin Cold Foam, and a canned Pumpkin Sh’pice Iced Coffee.
- Five snacks and bakery items, including returning Pumpkin Donut Holes and Apple Fritters.
My Sheetz Rewardz members get the fall shakes for $5 through October 27, 2026. As of October 12, Sheetz hasn’t announced any Halloween drinks for 2026.
The Full Fall 2026 Lineup
| Item | What it is | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin Pie Milkshake | Vanilla ice cream, dulce, pumpkin pie spices | Shake (new) |
| Pumpkin Cheezecake Milkshake | Vanilla shake, cheesecake filling, pumpkin spice, whipped cream, graham crumbs | Shake (new) |
| Cereal Chiller Milkshake | Vanilla shake blended with fruity rice cereal | Shake (new) |
| Pumpkin Chai | Chai with pumpkin and caramel; hot, iced or frozen | Coffee & tea |
| Pumpkin Cold Foam | Pumpkin-caramel foam made with protein milk | Coffee topper |
| Pumpkin Sh’pice Canned Iced Coffee | Ready-to-drink can | Cooler aisle |
| Shweetz Pumpkin Donut Holes | Pumpkin donut holes | Bakery (returning) |
| Apple Fritters | Fall fritter | Bakery (returning) |
| Gimme Sh’more Snack Tray | Marshmallow fluff, mini chocolate chips, graham sticks | Snack (new) |
| Sh’pice Cookie | Soft molasses cookie with warm spices | Bakery (new) |
| Blueberry Açaí Smoothie Cup | Dragonfruit, açaí, blueberries, Greek yogurt, chia pudding | Grab-and-go cup (new) |
The Fall Shakes and the $5 Deal
The Pumpkin Pie Milkshake keeps it simple: vanilla ice cream, dulce and pumpkin pie spices.
The Pumpkin Cheezecake Milkshake is the richer of the two. It’s a vanilla shake blended with cheesecake filling made with Philadelphia cream cheese, then topped with whipped cream and graham cracker crumbs.
The Cereal Chiller isn’t pumpkin at all. It’s a vanilla shake blended with fruity rice cereal, there for anyone who’s done with pumpkin spice.
The deal: Sheetz’s Rewardz promotions page lists “$5 Fall Shakez,” valid from September 2 through October 27, 2026. You need a My Sheetz Rewardz account to get that price, so order in the app or scan your account at the kiosk. After October 27, expect regular shake pricing if the flavors are still around.
Calories (16 oz):
| Shake | Calories | Carbs | Protein |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin Pie | 820 | 134g | 8g |
| Pumpkin Cheezecake | 925 | 129g | 11g |
These figures come from nutrition databases that carry Sheetz data. One older listing puts the Pumpkin Pie shake at 660, so check your size in the app. Either way, the fall shakes are among the heaviest drinks Sheetz sells. If you want a regular flavor instead, our guide covers the year-round shake flavors.
Pumpkin Coffee and Chai
Pumpkin Chai is the new headliner. It’s chai blended with pumpkin and caramel flavors, and you can order it hot, iced or frozen. Frozen is the dessert version; iced keeps it closer to a regular chai.
Pumpkin Cold Foam is a pumpkin-caramel foam made with protein milk. You can add it to any Sheetz Bros. coffee drink, which turns a plain cold brew into a fall drink without ordering a full specialty latte.
Pumpkin Sh’pice Canned Iced Coffee is a can in the cooler aisle, with pumpkin and seasonal spice. It’s the grab-and-go option when you don’t want to wait for the kiosk.
Reports differ on how long these last. Some coverage called the whole menu limited-time; one report said the new coffee drinks would stay on the menu. Check the app for your store. For the regular drinks behind these toppers, see our Sheetz Bros. coffee guide.
Fall Bakery and Snacks
- Shweetz Pumpkin Donut Holes: a returning favorite. They sit with the rest of the Sheetz donuts.
- Apple Fritters: also back for fall.
- Gimme Sh’more Snack Tray: a cup of marshmallow fluff topped with mini chocolate chips, with graham sticks for dipping. Basically campfire s’mores without the fire.
- Sh’pice Cookie: a soft, chewy molasses cookie with warm spices.
- Blueberry Açaí Smoothie Cup: dragonfruit, açaí, blueberries, vanilla Greek yogurt and chia pudding. Sheetz lists 15g of protein and 7g of fiber, making it the one fall item built for nutrition rather than indulgence.
The cookie and donut holes join the regular Shweetz bakery lineup for the season.
The Other Fall Drop: “Fuel Stop Feast” Items
Also starting September 2, Sheetz added three limited-time items from its “Fuel Stop Feast” mini-series with First We Feast, hosted by Adam Richman:
- Lumberjack Breakfast Sandwich: pork sausage patty, bacon and scrambled eggs, plus a honey bun, between two waffles.
- Pizza Bagel Bunz Burger: a burger with pizza bagels in place of the bun.
- Tater Bomb Nachos: Tater Bombs topped with chicken strips, peppers, onions, nacho cheese and jalapeño potato chips.
They aren’t pumpkin items, but they’re part of the same fall window. Availability may vary by now, so search the app before you drive over for one.
Does Sheetz Have Halloween Drinks in 2026?
Not yet. As of October 12, 2026, Sheetz hasn’t announced a Halloween lineup, and the Rewardz promotions page shows no Halloween offers.
Sheetz has run Halloween drinks in past years, though, and they followed a pattern:
| Year | Halloween drinks | Price | Ran until |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Vanilla Thriller Cold Brew, Candy Bag Milkshake, Transfuzion Refresher | $3.19 for the cold brew; $3.99 each with Rewardz for the shake and Refresher | Nov 1 |
| 2020 | Dracuccino, Sour Applez, Monster Mash shake | $3.99 each | Nov 1 |
Past Halloween drinks were announced in mid-to-late October and ran through November 1. If Sheetz does a 2026 version, that’s the window to watch. We’ll add any 2026 Halloween items here once Sheetz confirms them.
How Long Does the Fall Menu Last?
- $5 Fall Shakez: through October 27, 2026, per Sheetz’s Rewardz page.
- Everything else: limited-time, with no published end date. Seasonal items usually leave as the holiday menu arrives.
- Pumpkin coffee items: may outlast the rest, so check the app.
The fastest way to see what’s still available is to choose your store in the Sheetz app. Items that have ended stop appearing there.
FAQ
When did the Sheetz fall menu come out in 2026?
September 2, 2026, at all Sheetz locations.
How much are the Sheetz fall shakes?
$5 each for My Sheetz Rewardz members through October 27, 2026. Without the Rewardz price, they cost the regular shake price at your store.
Does Sheetz have pumpkin spice coffee?
Yes. This fall, Sheetz offers Pumpkin Chai (hot, iced or frozen), Pumpkin Cold Foam for any Sheetz Bros. coffee, and a canned Pumpkin Sh’pice Iced Coffee.
Are Sheetz Pumpkin Donut Holes back?
Yes. Shweetz Pumpkin Donut Holes returned with the fall 2026 menu, along with Apple Fritters.
Will Sheetz have Halloween drinks this year?
Nothing was announced as of October 12, 2026. In past years, Sheetz released Halloween drinks in October that ran through November 1.